For she’s a jolly good “fellow”

May 31, 2010 | by Naureen | No Comments

In this era of “law firm fellows,” what does it meant to be, well, a non-law firm fellow? A friend with a coveted post-graduate project-based fellowship recently complained to me that she earns far less than law firm volunteers, a.k.a. “law firm fellows,” who typically see their firm salaries dwindle to half or a third of their former selves. Ouch! Just kidding.

The salary discrepancy makes for awkward “What’d you do last weekend?” conversations, but the costs to perennial public interest fellows is much greater: thanks to the influx of “law firm fellows,” the term “fellow” is being rapidly diluted. (Of course, lay-people have long mistaken it for a non-job title, asking me the question most damning to a recent law school graduate, “So, what are you studying?”)

Now, even within the public interest law field, the term “fellow” has been thrown into ambiguity. What does it mean to be a “legal fellow”? Career public interest lawyers, stuck in the pre-”3 to 5 years” experience range, often gain positions as fellows. But increasingly, the term also applies to volunteer attorneys who may only stick around until the economy rebounds.

Which one is really a public interest law fellow? Attribution: Jakob E (Flickr, 2008)

Little is more important to the success of a young attorney than her ability to build credibility, to hoard cachet. Rightly or wrongly (yes, sometimes wrongly), volunteer attorneys on “furlough” from their law firms are considered by some to merely be full-time, extra-competent interns.

For a public interest lawyer determined to stick around, being mistaken for a full-time intern after landing one of your first full-time jobs as a lawyer is more than disheartening. It’s disastrous for our ability to be taken seriously, to get our work done.

Don’t get mad, get a better title. There’s no reason why we should resign ourselves to the term “fellow.” Recognizing the diminished value and meaning of the term, fellowship supervisors should be open to changing our titles. Here are a few ideas:

Do those help? Let us know what you think are some palatable replacements.

Comment on this post

Also Featured

Photo: Are you my mentor?
Are you my mentor?

Photo: Loyalty is a One-Way St.
Loyalty is a One-Way St.

Photo: Your liberation is mine, all mine
Your liberation is mine, all mine

Contribute to greatrgood

We love comments. Leave us comments! We also love guest posts and new additions to our team. Please take a look at the About page and get to know the GG spirit and mission. Then shoot us an e-mail to run a topic by us and introduce yourself.

Peer Review »


Photo: For she’s a jolly good “fellow”
For she’s a jolly good “fellow”

What does it mean to be a “legal fellow”? Career public interest lawyers, stuck in the pre-”3 to 5 years” experience range, often gain positions as fellows. But increasingly, the term also applies to volunteer attorneys who may only stick around until the economy rebounds.

Advice »


Photo: Loyalty is a One-Way St.
Loyalty is a One-Way St.

I realized I had absolutely no advice about job negotiations — I’ve never negotiated a position. Even this year, as for the first time I have been in a position of not-exactly-groveling, I find myself unable to ask my kindly employers for anything.

Trending »


Photo: Are you my mentor?
Are you my mentor?

The public interest sector appears to be failing to mentor young, PI attorneys and PI attorneys-to-be. It’s an arguable proposition, but jump with me to the more important question: why this failure? Are we just un-mentorable?

Ed. Note »


Photo: There’s a Reason We Do It, Pt. 1
There’s a Reason We Do It, Pt. 1

Today is the first day of the Chinese New Year. It is the day before George Washington’s birthday. It is two days after Abraham Lincoln’s birthday. It is Valentine’s Day, too.
You should be out. You should not be reading this. You should not be sitting at a computer. You should not be scrolling your way [...]


social

archives